Corn

How many kernels on an ear of corn? we asked the third and fourth graders the other day. They've been studying the Mayan people, who called themselves "People of the Corn," so it was a worthwhile question.

We started by having students find approximations; as you should know by now if you've been reading this blog, us Math Guys consider this a very important step. We asked students to choose a round number (a number that is a multiple of 10); the point, after all, wasn't to guess the exact number, but to use a number that makes some sense and is relatively easy to work with. You can always revise your estimate later, we assured them.



What is the estimate based on? Well, we gave them each an ear of dried corn to eyeball. Some did some quick-n-dirty calculations, fourth graders in particular. (Yes, we asked them to justify their reasoning. Some of them HATE this, but it's oh-so-good for them.)

"About 20 in each row," wrote one student. "Maybe 10 rows. 10 x 20 = 200. I estimate 200 kernels in all."

"I think there are 20 rows and 30 in each row," reported someone else, "but that might not be enough so I added a few more. I say 640."

"I think 260," wrote a third grader, who would have been happy to leave it at that, but who added, under duress from a teacher, "because it looks right. And because it's a good number." We might call this strategy "Pick-a-large-number, any-large-number, and-assign-it-great-virtue-so-critics-will-be-cowed."



The next step: Count the kernels! The classroom teachers had prepared egg cartons with ten cuplets (better them than me). Kids used their fingernails to push the kernels off the cob (great fun). Then they distributed the kernels 5 or 10 at a time into the cups, making groups of 50 or 100. Record the number, dump out the kernels, lather, rinse, repeat.



At some point along the way several students noticed that their estimates weren't looking as accurate as they had back before counting had begun. This was especially true for those whose initial strategy had been "Pick-a-large-number, any-large-number &c," but other more careful estimators ran into this difficulty too. No problem! we said. Just revise your estimate, record it--oh, and explain why you wanted to change your original prediction. (My favorite: "Because I passed my first estimate a long time ago.") You will no doubt be shocked to learn that the second set of estimates were considerably closer than the first.

Eventually, all corn kernels were off the cobs and had traveled through the eggcups and into plastic bowls or paper bags (except for a few strays which had found their way onto the floor), and everyone had an exact answer. Some were surprised to see how many there were. Others found the results unsurprising in the extreme, or claimed they did: "I knew it," crowed one boy whose answer was not, perhaps, as close as he thought.

As students finished, they compared their totals with friends and thought about questions such as Why aren't all the totals the same?, What could you do to get a better estimate next time? ("Nothing," said the young man quoted above), and About how many kernels do you think there might be in the whole class?

So, three-digit numbers, ordering, estimating, grouping by tens, fives, 50s, and 100s, and explaining reasoning. Plus, a fun project (there's something truly satisfying about flicking those kernels off the cob, and something even more satisfying about running your fingers through a nice big tub full of everyone's kernels), and one that relates to science and social studies. A worthwhile math period indeed. Next up: data analysis with these results. On Thursday we'll be in the Chapman Room calculating the median and range of the data and forming a Living Histogram. Pictures to follow, assuming my camera behaves itself...