Sunday, May 3, 2009

George's Excellent Adventure

Sometimes the best lessons are the ones you don't plan.

Friday morning, Ellen poked her head into the office as I was preparing for a fraction lesson with the 1-2s. "Elizabeth found a Where's George dollar in her lunch money," she said. "Okay if we take a few minutes to enter it at the beginning of math time today?"

Where's George, I should explain, is a lovely internet project that tracks paper money as it moves across the country (www.wheresgeorge.com). Since the 3-4 classes handle lots of money in their capacity as Pizza People, they occasionally run into Where's George bills, which are recognizable by special markings. We log onto the site, enter the bill's serial number, note our location, and press Enter. If the sound on my laptop is turned on, we'll then hear a cash register noise and the bill's previous location(s) will appear. Most of the bills we've found thus far have come from nearby places such as Pennsylvania and Massachusetts, Brooklyn and Kingston, but we've had bills from Missouri, Tennessee, and Texas as well. It's fun, and suspenseful, and teaches a bit about geography--and you never know when someone will find "our" bill and put it in again.

When we entered Elizabeth's bill, the screen showed that the bill was now 1128 miles from its original location. I had a sudden brainstorm. Instead of scrolling down and telling the class where the bill had come from, I'd have them narrow the possibilities by using math--specifically, their measuring and estimation skills. They'd been working on maps all year long, after all, filling in states that Cheerful Charlie had visited in his round-the-US tour. Ellen got one of the students' maps, and we hung it up. We determined that 1128 was very close to 1100, in double-round numbers, and at 200 miles to the inch, the class quickly calculated that the starting point was about 5.5 inches away from us.

It was clear to most of the students that the possibilities would form the arc of a circle, and so we did a little measuring. We ended up with a curve beginning at the western end of Michigan's Upper Peninsula and then zagging through Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, Arkansas, and Mississippi--all of them marked on the students' maps--before catching a piece of south-central Florida and disappearing over the Atlantic Ocean. "Why can't the bill have started here?" I asked, indicating where the arc crossed the Gulf of Mexico. That was obvious. "It's too wet for money in the ocean," a third grader answered (unless, he added, there were islands he "didn't know about"). As for why we didn't go north of Michigan, that was obvious too: Canada has its own money.

I scrolled down on the webpage and revealed the answer: the bill had originated in Florida. ("I knew it!" half the class exclaimed.) I named the town, which I'd never heard of. But Ellen had: her brother lived there. She asked if there was any way to find out who started the bill on its travels. Well, yes, there was; I clicked on the profile button and found a first name, Bob.

It wasn't Ellen's brother. But that was all right. Bob had provided us with a nice map of the US, each state filled in with one of six colors. Now I had my second brainstorm. We'd done a little real-life estimating and measuring with scale; it was time for some real-world data analysis.

"What do you think this map shows?" I asked, turning the computer so the students could see. Temperatures, guessed one boy. Good thought, but no. How many people live in each state? asked a girl. Close, I said. Think about what website this is, Ellen suggested, and suddenly hands were flying up all over the meeting area. Bob, they realized, had marked dozens and dozens of bills and sent them into the wild. The colors showed how many of those bills had turned up in each state.


[Here is Bob's Hit Map, by the way:]

Right on the money! (So to speak.) The only question now was which colors stood for the most bills and which for the fewest. To help, I had them identify a few key states on Bob's map, and then I gave them a little extra information. California, I explained, had the most people of any state. Texas, New York, and Florida were next. Wyoming took up a lot of space, but it had fewer people than any other state.

Working as a group, the class swiftly came up with a sensible schematic for the colors. Red, the color of Florida, California, and New York, would be the most. Bright green, it seemed apparent, would be next, judging from what the children knew of population and distance, and so on, down to lowly Wyoming, the only state that was colored gray.

The guesses were in. It was now time for the Great Unveiling. I had everyone's full attention: they were deeply invested in the outcome by now. And the results were entirely satisfactory. The class had four out of six colors right; the only error had been reversing the orderof the fourth- and fifth-most colors.

Not bad, not bad at all, I told them, and we moved on to the regularly scheduled lesson on division.

No comments:

Post a Comment